BreakPoint Blog

Banner
Banner
The Ugly Side of Humanism
Topics: Worldview

It’s astonishing, really, but many humanists think that if they only built better buildings, the “perfectibility” of mankind could be achieved. All it takes to perfect man, they think, is stellar blueprints with a bit of elbow grease. This idea is what philosophers call "the myth of progress." It is a utopian dream whereby mankind can engineer salvation through architecture.

The humanists are correct about one thing, “Building houses and designing them is a religious activity," as Alan Wilson says in "Religion of Works."

In the area of architecture, humanism has had dire consequences. The more committed the humanist’s dream of salvation through human effort, the uglier their designs have become. Wilson asserts that, "[N]o other art form has been so plagued with messianic dreams than architectural design, especially in the twentieth century."

Perfectibility of man only comes from acknowledging our sin and accepting salvation through the Cross, but when we insist on saving ourselves, failure is inevitable. Look at any public housing project, of instance, and you will see a bunch of ugly buildings—buildings which people hate to enter.

Ultimately, all the humanists effort for salvation through design is in vain. With former residents cheering on the sidelines, many of the housing projects have been blown to smithereens.


Comments:

It's probably a bit too early for all of us to burst out singing "Gina's the best; we all miss her; things just fall apart whenever she's gone;..." but we should probably start getting our voices warmed up.

Besides, they're all humming it to themselves in the hallways of PFM HQ anyway. Us Pointificators can just join in.

And yes, Rolley, you can have the "Woohoo!" solo; your audition was perfect. And while the black-feathered outfit was a nice touch, it won't be needed for the final performance.
Not a Problem, Dave
.
I was just fearful that I may have stumbled upon yet another rip in the fabric of the space-time continuum where unpaired socks, ivory-billed woodpeckers, and keenly incisive Point comments randomly disappear only to reappear when least expected in the form of “off-topic” remarks and duck-like outbursts.

I’ve seen it happen more than once. I told The Point’s General Manager, Mr. Daewoo, who agreed editorial vigilance is necessary to keep such phenomena at a minimum.

You know, the Mr. Daewoo who famously said, “the worst thing about a duck dinner is the bill”; the Mr. Daewoo who said the difference between a one-winged duck and a two-winged duck is a matter of a pinion; the Mr. Daewoo who….

Yes, THAT Mr. Daewoo. Who knew?
Oops
Rolley:

Not lost, not edited . . . we're just a bit short staffed with Gina Dalfonzo on vacation.

We do have to "approve" comments before they go live (we do get some comments that are way off topic or simply inappropriate), and with Gina gone, sometimes it takes a little longer.

Sorry for the inconvenience and the delay!

DtS
Testing Testing Testing
.
My comments seem to be getting lost.

OR MAYBE THEY’RE GETTING EDITED.

Horrors. Talk to me, Kim, lest self-doubt plunge me into the extremities of disquietude.
That Stairway Up Goes Down
.
Peter Eisenman, architect of that tribute to “the beauty of meaninglessness” (the Wexner Center) was once asked, “what are you afraid of regarding the future?” He answered: “Death. I'm scared to death, not to be forever. I don't worry about money, work, anything else, but I can't come to terms with the idea of going to sleep one night and not waking up. It's the only thing I worry about, and I have to not think about it, because I would go crazy. Being dead is an awful thought.”

One small step for a man, one giant leap for mankind.
That Stairway Up Goes Down
.
Peter Eisenman, architect of that tribute to “the beauty of meaninglessness” (the Wexner Center) was once asked, “what are you afraid of regarding the future?” He answered: “Death. I'm scared to death, not to be forever. I don't worry about money, work, anything else, but I can't come to terms with the idea of going to sleep one night and not waking up. It's the only thing I worry about, and I have to not think about it, because I would go crazy. Being dead is an awful thought.”

One small step for a man, one giant leap for mankind.
The stairway to nowhere is:
Wexner Center for the Arts at the Ohio State University. Here's a link some pictures of the architectural mess.

On a recent broadcast of his, Ravi Zacharias said he was once shown what the architect of it proudly called "the first post-modernist building ever built". It had walls at odd angles, staircases that led nowhere, and a general absence of the functionality and utility one would expect in a building.

Ravi asked his tour guide "Did the architect take the same approach with the building's foundation?" and got only stunned silence in response.
It used to be considered a charity project for squires to knock down their peasant's huts and rebuild them in stone. The peasants tended to be ambiguous about the enterprise to say the least although they did get better residencies out of the deal in the end.